|
From the
Editor: In response to readers requests weve chosen
to highlight several publications relating to issues around immigration
and the increasing cultural and religious diversity on this island.
THE ISSUE OF
ASYLUM and Immigration is comprehensively addressed in the book
Asylum and Immigration, a Christian Perspective on a Polarised
Debate by Nick Spencer, Paternoster Jubilee Centre, 2004. Though
statistics, and legislation, can be out of date as soon as they
hit the page, this book gives careful consideration to a notoriously
slippery subject (based on UK examples), clarifying language and
seeking to focus on the underlying principles of the debate. The
extensive sections addressing biblical teaching on issues such as
nationhood, ethnicity and the treatment of the alien
or stranger in the communitys midst, make it widely applicable
and a real aid to getting to grips with these issues.
On a different
tack, Stephen Skuces The Faiths of Ireland, Columba
Press, 2006, explores and explains the faith of newcomers and some
longer established non-Christian faith communities, while also unearthing
intriguing stories of Irish interaction with people of other faiths
in the past. It is a valuable and interesting look at the contemporary
religious landscape of Ireland and increases understanding of other
faiths.
But how do
Christian new residents fit in to the religious landscape?
For some, the answer has been to establish their own churches alongside
the existing denominations. Others have chosen the path of integration
in the Irish churches.
Mercia Malcolm
takes a look at a publication exploring the issues and challenges
of integration in this context
No Longer
Strangers. Cultural Integration in Church and Society in Ireland.
A Doctrine and Life Special, Dominican Publications (Oct 2006).
This special issue of the Dominican Publications journal,
edited and introduced by Bernard Treacy O.P., reflects upon the
experiences of a growing number of congregations in the Republic
of Ireland, mainly from the Protestant denominations, and the challenges
and enrichment brought about by the influx in recent years of new
members from immigrant communities.
Tony Walsh,
a lecturer in Adult and Community Education in NUI, Maynooth, begins
by considering, The Trauma of Cultural Displacement.
Two further chapters reflect on the direct experiences of people
in culturally diverse Christian communities in Ireland and the changes
produced by those experiences in both church and society. There
is inevitably considerable overlap here, but he offers a clear analysis
of the process of change and of the challenges and excitements involved.
In the most
extended chapter, The Ephesian Moment: the Possibilities of
Cultural Reconciliation in a Cosmopolitan Environment Alan
Martin, a retired Presbyterian minister, formerly of Abbey Church
in Dublin, analyses the way communities of the early church grappled
with cultural diversity and issues of integration, finding the greatest
vision of integration when the dividing walls are broken down by
the reconciling power of the cross. It is a thought provoking and
stimulating vision of how openness to transcultural experiences
can transform both the church and the surrounding society.
An examination
of the sociological factors that facilitate integration proximity,
equality, authority and a sense of the common good frames
the discussion of what happened in the early church and what is
happening in modern-day Ireland. The key point is that proximity
alone is not enough to produce good relationships between culturally
diverse groups. Indeed, simply mixing people together can have very
negative results, fostering low-level racism or sectarianism and
subtly reinforcing divisions. The distinctively Christian elements
of forgiveness and repentance are seen as essential to the reconciliation
which can unite people of very different cultural backgrounds and
experiences.
Anne Ryan,
the head of the Department of Adult and Community Education at NUI,
Maynooth, contributes a helpful chapter describing different approaches
to engagement. These are assimilation, which eliminates difference
through absorption, multi-culturalism which retains the distinct
identities of cultures and inter-culturalism, in which identities
are retained by promoting understanding between cultures and transculturalism,
which promotes interaction, leading to change in each culture that
enhances all the cultures involved. Transculturalism is the most
difficult level of engagement to achieve, but she provides a very
inspiring vision of the benefits attached to such risky engagement.
Sahr Yambasu,
a teacher of theology from Sierra Leone, now Methodist minister
in Galway, contributes a fascinating Bible study on the encounter
between Peter and Cornelius, called Embracing the Different
Other, using some of the categories of encounter offered by
Miroslav Volf in his book, Exclusion and Embrace.
This timely
and stimulating book reveals that while it is unsettling to face
challenges to accepted norms in the encounter with those from other
cultures, where work, thought and care are employed in embracing
the different other it can be an enriching and positive experience
for all. This little book gives ample evidence that the benefits
far outweigh any difficulties.
|